The Client Who Said She Never Received the Logo Designs
A client viewed a designer's logo concepts, praised them, then filed a PayPal “item not received” dispute. What settled it, and what freelancers can take from it.
What happened
In a 2016 blog post, the designer behind the imjustcreative blog wrote that three clients had filed “Item not received” disputes with PayPal during 2015. One of them is described in detail.
The client had paid £1,000. The designer uploaded the first ideas and sketches to Cage, an online proofing tool, with notes explaining the thinking behind each one. The client logged in, looked at the ideas and left very positive feedback.
Two days later she asked PayPal for a full refund, saying she had not received the work. PayPal took the £1,000 out of the designer’s account and held it while it looked into the dispute.
How it was settled
The designer could show that the client had logged in to view the ideas, and what she had written about them, with screenshots to back it up. PayPal decided in the designer’s favour.
Where it went wrong
Nothing was wrong with the work. The weak spot was delivery itself. Creative work doesn’t leave a trail the way a parcel does: there’s no tracking number and no signature at the door. That makes “I never received it” an easier thing to claim, and a hard one to answer with only a sent email.
What helped the designer was a choice made long before anything went wrong: sharing the work through a tool that logged who looked at it. A lot of freelancers send concepts and final files as attachments or transfer links. Those show that something was sent, but not that anyone opened it.
What you can take from it
- Send work somewhere that records who opened it. A sent email shows that you sent something. A record of who viewed it shows that someone actually looked.
- Keep the client’s reactions in writing. Positive feedback on a concept also confirms that it arrived. If the feedback comes in by phone, send a short email afterwards that sums it up.
- Save screenshots while things are still friendly. The designer pointed out that clients can delete their own comments, so a screenshot taken on a good day can matter later.
- Know how your payment platform handles disputes before you need it. This one ran through PayPal, and the outcome depended on what PayPal accepted as evidence that the service was delivered. Those rules may well have changed since 2016.
Where SignToSee fits
This is one of the situations SignToSee is built for. When you send work as a SignToSee link, your client confirms their email with a code before anything opens, and you can see which address opened which file, and when. It records the open, not whether the client liked what they saw, so their feedback is still worth keeping.
Start free: every new account gets the Sign plan for its first week.
Source: “Graphic Designers: Avoid PayPal ‘Item not Received’ Dispute”, imjustcreative.com, 21 March 2016. We’ve retold the post in our own words; the details are the author’s own account.
Continue reading
How to Send Design Concepts and Proposals to Clients Before Approval
How freelance designers share previews and concepts before the client has signed: a link with your name on it, an optional NDA, and a record of who opened it.
Is a Click-to-Accept Signature Valid in the EU? What eIDAS Says (SES, AES, QES)
The difference between simple, advanced and qualified electronic signatures under eIDAS, and what a click-to-accept NDA does and does not prove in the EU.
Ready to stop sending bare links?
A link with your name on it, and a record of who opened it and when. It's free to start.
Start on the Free plan. No credit card required.